9 Best Compost Soil for 2024

(Many of the links in this article redirect to a specific reviewed product. Your purchase of these products through affiliate links helps to generate commission for Chicagolandgardening.com, at no extra cost. Learn more)

Introducing the 9 Best Compost Soil for 2023 – your definitive guide to finding the most superior compost options for all your gardening needs. As an expert content writer, I have meticulously researched and curated a selection of the top compost soils available on the market, taking into consideration factors such as nutrient content, organic composition, and environmental sustainability. Whether you’re an avid gardener or just starting out, this comprehensive list will ensure that you make an informed choice when it comes to enriching your soil and promoting healthy plant growth. Get ready to discover the finest compost soils that will transform your garden into a flourishing oasis of greenery in 2023 and beyond.

Ribbon Organics OMRI Certified Organic Compost

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9/10

Ribbon Organics OMRI Certified Organic Compost is a high-quality compost that improves soil structure and aeration while promoting water retention. This compost is specifically designed for organic use and is safe to use at any concentration. It pairs wonderfully with worm castings and other soil builders to create an optimal growing environment for your plants. With a size of 7.9 gallons and a weight of 32-35 pounds per bag, it provides ample compost for your gardening needs. The compost is black in color and has dimensions of 20.00Lx16.00Wx4.00H. It has received a customer rating of 4.7/5 based on positive reviews from satisfied gardeners.

Ribbon Organics OMRI Certified Organic Compost is a reliable choice for gardeners seeking high-quality compost to improve their soil. With its OMRI certification and organic composition, it ensures a healthy and sustainable gardening experience. The compost’s ability to enhance soil structure, promote water retention, and pair well with other soil builders makes it a versatile option for a variety of plants and gardens. While the product has received overwhelmingly positive reviews, the relatively higher price and occasional presence of uncomposted debris are notable drawbacks. Overall, if you are looking to provide your plants with the best possible growing conditions, Ribbon Organics OMRI Certified Organic Compost is a reliable and effective choice.

Michigan Peat Garden Magic Compost and Manure

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8.6/10

The Michigan Peat 5240 Garden Magic Compost and Manure is an odor-free blend of natural organic reed sedge peat and composted animal manure. It provides a natural nutrient content, making it ideal for improving a wide range of planting soils. Available in a 40-pound bag, this compost and manure mixture is perfect for revitalizing bare spots on lawns or enriching soil for flowers and plants. It has received rave reviews from customers who have experienced remarkable results with its use. Some customers have praised its effectiveness in promoting healthy plant growth, while others have praised its high quality and lack of impurities. However, a few customers have mentioned uneven quality in some batches, indicating a need for better quality control measures. Overall, the Michigan Peat 5240 Garden Magic Compost and Manure is a reliable and affordable product that delivers great value for garden enthusiasts.


The Michigan Peat 5240 Garden Magic Compost and Manure is a reliable and affordable product that garden enthusiasts can rely on. With its natural nutrient content, this compost and manure blend helps improve planting soils and promotes healthy plant growth. Customers have seen impressive results, with the product effectively revitalizing bare spots on lawns and enhancing the vibrancy of flowers and plants. While there have been a few reports of inconsistent quality in some batches, the majority of customers have been highly satisfied with the product’s performance. With its competitive price point and positive customer feedback, the Michigan Peat 5240 Garden Magic Compost and Manure is recommended for any gardener looking to nourish their plants and achieve beautiful, thriving gardens.

Old Potters Organic Compost

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8.5/10

Old Potters Organic Compost is a high-quality plant-based potting soil and garden fertilizer that nourishes your plants and boosts their growth. This 10-pound bag (8 quarts) is suitable for indoor and outdoor farming. Made from organic materials, this compost provides complete nutrients to your plants, ensuring healthy and thriving growth. Its texture is perfect for planting bulbs, starting seeds, or repotting existing plants. The compost mixes well with other soil types, making it versatile for various gardening needs. Although it is a bit pricey compared to store-bought compost, its quality and effectiveness make it worth the extra cost. Old Potters Organic Compost is a top choice for gardeners who want premium and nutrient-rich soil for their plants.

Old Potters Organic Compost is a premium potting soil and garden fertilizer that delivers exceptional results. Its organic composition and nutrient-rich formula provide optimum nourishment for plants, resulting in healthy growth. Whether you’re planting bulbs, starting seeds, or repotting existing plants, this compost’s texture is ideal for various gardening applications. While it may be slightly pricier than alternatives found in stores, the quality and effectiveness of Old Potters Organic Compost make it a worthwhile investment for serious gardeners. Give your plants the best possible start by choosing this top-notch compost that’s designed to maximize plant health and vitality.

Coast of Maine Vegetable Plant Potting Soil Compost Blend

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9/10

The Coast of Maine Listed Tomato and Vegetable Plant Potting Soil Compost Blend is a 2-pack of lightweight, organic compost potting soil blend that is ideal for tomatoes and vegetables. Each bag contains 20 quarts of potting soil, making it perfect for use in your container garden or professional farm. This dark brown blend of composts and nutrients provides everything your plants need to thrive. It is OMRI-listed and preservative-free, making it suitable for organic gardening operations. The balanced design encourages water retention and steady drainage, ensuring optimal growing conditions for your plants. Bring out the best in your vegetables with this high-quality potting soil blend.

With its nutrient-rich compost blend and balanced design, the Coast of Maine Listed Tomato and Vegetable Plant Potting Soil Compost Blend is a top choice for container gardens and flower pots. The 2-pack of lightweight and organic potting soil provides the perfect nourishment for tomatoes and vegetables, resulting in strong and healthy plants. Its suitability for organic gardening operations makes it an excellent option for those who prefer to garden organically. While some reviewers have pointed out its resemblance to Miracle Gro soil and the lack of loose dirt in the bag, the overall consensus is that this potting soil blend delivers exceptional results. Give your plants a thriving environment with this high-quality potting soil blend.

Super Compost Organic Plant Food

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The Super Compost by Soil Blend is a highly recommended gardening product that helps achieve larger yields and tastier fruits and vegetables. This 8 lb. bag of concentrated organic plant food is a nutrient-dense formula that promotes healthy plant growth. It is OMRI listed, approved by the American Vegetarian Association, and is NON-GMO. With a balanced 2-2-2 formula and the addition of calcium and iron, this compost provides essential nutrients for your plants. It is safe to use around people, pets, wildlife, and the environment. The Super Compost is odor-free and is perfect for gardening enthusiasts who want to see impressive results. However, some customers find the quantity of compost to be small considering the price. Overall, it is a great product that delivers excellent results.

The Super Compost by Soil Blend is a fantastic organic plant food that delivers impressive results. Its highly concentrated formula ensures larger yields and tastier fruits and vegetables. Recommended by customers, this compost is safe to use and odor-free. While some may find the quantity small considering the price, the overall quality and effectiveness of the product make it worth the investment. Whether you’re a seasoned gardener or just starting out, this Super Compost is an excellent choice to enhance the growth and health of your plants. Give it a try and experience the benefits firsthand!

Premium Organic Compost for Healthy Lawn and Garden Soil

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9/10

Wakefield Premium Compost is a 100% organic and OMRI-listed soil amendment that is perfect for creating healthy conditions in your lawn and garden. It is made in the USA from untreated wood feedstock and contains naturally occurring fungi and bacteria. This premium compost can be used for vegetable gardens, flower beds, trees, shrubs, new lawn seeding, and raised garden beds. It can be used as a top dressing for existing lawns and gardens or mixed with organic matter from compost bins. Safe and healthy for all types of plants and gardens, Wakefield Premium Compost is ready to use straight out of the bag.

Wakefield Premium Compost is a high-quality, organic compost that is highly regarded by customers. It is praised for its effectiveness in improving soil health and promoting strong plant growth. The compost is easy to use, whether as a soil amendment, a top dressing, or a component in composting. Customers have reported great results with their gardens, noting healthier plants and bountiful crops. The compost is also economically packaged in a large bag, ensuring that you have an ample supply. With its excellent quality and positive customer feedback, Wakefield Premium Compost is a reliable choice for gardeners looking to enhance their soil and achieve beautiful, thriving gardens.

Espoma Organic Land and Sea Gourmet Compost

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8/10

The Espoma Organic Land and Sea Gourmet Compost is the ultimate planting mix for your garden. This organic soil mix is enriched with both lobster and crab meal, providing the perfect blend of nutrients for your plants and vegetables. Whether you're planting in the garden or in containers, this compost is a must-have to improve soil quality and invigorate container mixes. It contains a blend of natural and organic ingredients, with no synthetic plant foods or chemicals. The Espoma Organic Land and Sea Gourmet Compost is easy to use and delivers great results, helping your plants thrive and grow. It's no wonder that gardeners everywhere consider Espoma products the best choice for their plants.

The Espoma Organic Land and Sea Gourmet Compost is a top choice for gardeners looking to improve soil quality and enhance plant growth. With its blend of natural and organic ingredients, enriched with lobster and crab meal, this compost provides the perfect nutrients for all plants and vegetables. It’s easy to use and delivers excellent results, making it a favorite among gardeners. However, it’s worth noting that this compost can be more expensive compared to local sources, and there have been some issues with packaging resulting in soil leakage. Overall, if you’re willing to invest in high-quality organic compost, the Espoma Organic Land and Sea Gourmet Compost is definitely worth considering.

Fort Vee – Organic Potting Soil Mix

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 9.5/10

The Vermont Compost Company Fort Vee is a high-nutrient, compost-based potting soil mix that is perfect for indoor and outdoor container seed starting, plants, and vegetables organic gardening. This organic potting soil is made from all-natural ingredients, providing your plants with the nutrients they need to grow naturally. It is specially designed for soil blocks, trays, and pots, making it an excellent choice for heavy feeders that require more nutrients. The premium potting soil mix is easy to use and guarantees healthy and strong plants. It has been tested for indoor and outdoor gardening and comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. Get your plants off to a great start with this nutrient-boosted potting mix.

The Vermont Compost Company Fort Vee is a top-quality organic potting soil mix that delivers exceptional results. It provides the nutrients needed for healthy plant growth and is specially designed for heavy feeders. With its easy-to-use formula and all-natural ingredients, it’s a must-have for both indoor and outdoor gardening. While it may be a bit pricey for some, the results are worth the investment. However, a few reviewers mentioned the presence of metal and sticks in their bags, so it’s important to check the product upon arrival. Overall, if you’re looking for a nutrient-boosted potting mix to give your plants a great start, the Fort Vee is an excellent choice.

Concentrated Organic Plant Fertilizer for Improved Garden Soil

Check Latest Price

This product has a rating of A.*What does this rating mean?

Overall Score: 8.4/10

Charlie's Compost is a concentrated organic plant fertilizer designed to improve garden soil and potting soil. It is made from high-quality compost inputs, including vegetarian & antibiotic-free chicken manure, biochar, and organic grasses, making it safe and appropriate for use in organic vegetable, fruit, and plant cultivation. Unlike synthetic fertilizers that only address the symptoms of soil deficiency, Charlie's Compost cures it by adding essential nutrients, microorganisms, and organic matter critical for soil health. With its concentrated formula, even a small amount can fertilize the most deficient soils, resulting in beautiful, healthy, and vibrant plants. Suitable for flower and vegetable gardens, as well as indoor and outdoor plants.

Charlie’s Compost is a high-quality, concentrated organic fertilizer that delivers noticeable results in garden and potting soil. It effectively boosts soil health, enhances plant growth, and provides beautiful and vibrant plants. The product’s certified organic nature ensures safe cultivation practices. The only downsides are the relatively small amount provided for the price and its higher cost compared to other compost options. However, considering the benefits it offers, Charlie’s Compost is a worthwhile investment for those seeking to improve the quality of their garden soil and nurture healthy plants.

Buyer's Guide: Compost Soil

Benefits of Compost Soil:

• 1. Nutrient-rich: Compost soil is a natural fertilizer that enhances the nutrient content of the soil, providing essential elements for plant growth.
• 2. Improves soil structure: The organic matter in compost improves soil structure, allowing better root penetration, moisture retention, and drainage.
• 3. Enhances plant growth: Compost soil stimulates plant growth by promoting healthier root systems, increasing resistance to diseases, and improving overall plant vigor.
• 4. Reduces waste: Composting helps divert organic waste from landfills, contributing to sustainable waste management and reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
• 5. Environmentally friendly: By using compost soil, you contribute to the preservation of the environment, as it reduces the need for synthetic fertilizers and chemical additives.
• 6. Cost-effective: Compost soil can be produced at home, eliminating the need to purchase expensive synthetic fertilizers, making it a cost-effective option for gardening.
• 7. Long-lasting effects: Unlike synthetic fertilizers that have short-term effects, compost soil improves soil health in the long run and sustains its benefits over time.

Factors to Consider when Buying Compost Soil:

• 1. Organic certification: Look for compost soil that has organic certification to ensure it meets strict standards and is free from harmful chemicals or contaminants.
• 2. Ingredients: Check the ingredients used in the compost soil. A balance of various organic materials such as vegetable scraps, leaves, grass clippings, and wood chips provides a diverse range of nutrients.
• 3. Texture and Moisture: Consider the texture and moisture content of the compost soil. It should have a crumbly texture, not clumpy, and should be moist but not overly wet.
• 4. Maturity: The maturity of compost soil is important. Fully matured compost will have an earthy smell, dark color, and a fine, crumbly texture.
• 5. pH level: Compost soil should ideally have a neutral pH level (around 6.5-7). This ensures it will suit a wide range of plants and won't adversely affect their growth.
• 6. Storage and Packaging: Check how the compost soil is stored and packaged. It should be stored in a cool, dry place and properly sealed to retain its quality.
• 7. Reviews and Recommendations: Read reviews and seek recommendations from trusted sources to ensure the compost soil you choose has a good track record for quality and effectiveness.